This paper presents a three-step validation approach for subjective rating predictions of driving simulator motion incongruences based on objective mismatches between reference vehicle and simulator motion. This approach relies on using high-resolution rating predictions of open-loop driving (participants being driven) for ratings of motion in closed-loop driving (participants driving themselves). A driving simulator experiment in an urban scenario is described, of which the rating data of 36 participants was recorded and analyzed. In the experiment’s first phase, participants actively drove themselves (i.e., closed-loop). By recording the drives of the participants and playing these back to themselves (open-loop) in the second phase, participants experienced the same motion in both phases. Participants rated the motion after each maneuver and at the end of each drive. In the third phase they again drove open-loop, but rated the motion continuously, only possible in open-loop driving. Results show that a rating model, acquired through a different experiment, can well predict the measured continuous ratings. Second, the maximum of the measured continuous ratings correlates to both the maneuver-based ( $\rho =0.94$ ) and overall ( $\rho =0.69$ ) ratings, allowing for predictions of both rating types based on the continuous rating model. Third, using Bayesian statistics it is then shown that both the maneuver-based and overall ratings between the closed-loop and open-loop drives are equivalent. This allows for predictions of maneuver-based and overall ratings using the high-resolution continuous rating models. These predictions can be used as an accurate trade-off method of motion cueing settings of future closed-loop driving simulator experiments.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Predicting Motion Incongruence Ratings in Closed- and Open-Loop Urban Driving Simulation


    Contributors:


    Publication date :

    2025-01-01


    Size :

    12294898 byte




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English



    Optimizing an Optimization-Based MCA using Perceived Motion Incongruence Models

    Cleij, D. / Pool, D. M. / Mulder, M. et al. | TIBKAT | 2020


    Closed loop driving device

    PARK DAE YEOB / BAEK SEUNG CHAN / HWANG IL SOON et al. | European Patent Office | 2022

    Free access

    Open and closed loop accelerometers

    McLaren, I. | TIBKAT | 1974


    Longitudinal Control for closed loop simulation of Autonomous driving Vehicle

    Kumbhare, Bhuvana / Akant, Kalyani / Khanapurkar, Milind et al. | IEEE | 2023


    Automatic driving closed-loop information system

    CAO CHUMU / CAO JINMO / CAO CHUNGENG | European Patent Office | 2020

    Free access