New NASA launch vehicles will require development of robust systems in a fiscally-constrained environment. NASA, Department of Defense (DoD), and commercial space companies routinely conduct ground vibration tests as an essential part of math model validation and launch vehicle certification. Although ground vibration testing must be a part of the integrated test planning process, more affordable approaches must also be considered. A study evaluated several ground vibration test options for the NASA Constellation Program flight test vehicles, Orion-1 and Orion-2, which concluded that more affordable ground vibration test options are available. The motivation for ground vibration testing is supported by historical examples from NASA and DoD. The approach used in the present study employed surveys of ground vibration test subject-matter experts that provided data to qualitatively rank six test options. Twenty-five experts from NASA, DoD, and industry provided scoring and comments for this study. The current study determined that both element-level modal tests and integrated vehicle modal tests have technical merits. Both have been successful in validating structural dynamic math models of launch vehicles. However, element-level testing has less overall cost and schedule risk as compared to integrated vehicle testing. Future NASA launch vehicle development programs should anticipate that some structural dynamics testing will be necessary. Analysis alone will be inadequate to certify a crew-capable launch vehicle. At a minimum, component and element structural dynamic tests are recommended for new vehicle elements. Three viable structural dynamic test options were identified. Modal testing of the new vehicle elements and an integrated vehicle test on the mobile launcher provided the optimal trade between technical, cost, and schedule.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Ground Vibration Testing Options for Space Launch Vehicles


    Contributors:

    Conference:

    JANNAF 8th Modeling and Simulaiton Subcommittee Meeting ; 2011 ; Huntsville, AL, United States
    JANNAF 6th Liquid Propulsion Subcommittee Meeting ; 2011 ; Huntsville, AL, United States
    JANNAF 5th Spacecraft Propulsion Subcommittee Meeting ; 2011 ; Huntsville, AL, United States


    Publication date :

    2011-12-05


    Type of media :

    Conference paper


    Type of material :

    No indication


    Language :

    English




    Objectives and Progress on Ground Vibration Testing for the Ares Launch Vehicles

    Tuma, Margaret / Askins, Bruce / Chenevert, Donald | AIAA | 2009


    Objectives and Progress on Ground Vibration Testing for the Ares Launch Vehicles

    M. L. Tuma / B. R. Askins / D. J. Chenevert | NTIS | 2009


    Objectives and Progress on Ground Vibration Testing for the Ares Launch Vehicles

    Tuma, M. / Askins, B. / Chenevert, D. et al. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2009


    Objectives and Progress on Ground Vibration Testing for the Ares Launch Vehicles

    Tuma, Margaret L. / Askins, Bruce R. / Chenevert, Donald J. | NTRS | 2009


    Analysis of post-mission disposal options of space launch vehicles

    Ayala Fernández, Lucía / Wiedemann, Carsten / Braun, Vitali | BASE | 2024

    Free access